Skip to main content

Model comparison

Ideogram 4.6 vs Seedream 5.5

We ran the same six prompts on Ideogram 4.6 and Seedream 5.5, in the same shape and at 2K. One try each, with one exception. The first Ideogram 4.6 portrait came out with the wrong proportions, so we ran that one a second time.

Try Ideogram 4.6

The short answer

  • Seedream 5.5 costs less: 1 credit at 2K. Ideogram 4.6 is 2 credits at Medium quality.
  • Ideogram 4.6 goes up to 4K. Seedream 5.5 stops at 2K.
  • Ideogram 4.6 has Precise Edit, which changes one thing and hands the photo back at its own size.
  • Both can return a see-through PNG.
  • Ideogram 4.6 was faster here: 13 to 31 seconds an image against 31 to 47.
  • Seedream 5.5 made the tighter, sharper portrait, and on its first try.

At a glance

Ideogram 4.6Seedream 5.5
Made byIdeogramByteDance
Price at 2K2 credits at Medium quality1 credit
Highest resolution4K2K
See-through backgroundYes, as a PNGYes, as a PNG
Reference imagesUp to 5Up to 10
Precise EditYesNo
Time per image in this test13 to 31 seconds31 to 47 seconds

Three signs in one photo

Ideogram 4.6: Three signs in one photo
Ideogram 4.6
Seedream 5.5: Three signs in one photo
Seedream 5.5

Both got all three signs right. Ideogram 4.6 stood her in the middle of a wide shop with the sign straight overhead and one beam of low sun. Seedream 5.5 framed her closer by a bright window, with a painted sign and warmer light on her face.

Photograph on a 35mm lens at eye level: a beautiful woman in her late twenties with long glossy chestnut hair, bright green eyes, flawless glowing skin and a radiant smile, in a fitted cream knit top and a mustard corduroy jacket, stands behind the counter of a small plant shop at golden hour, holding a terracotta pot with a fern. A hand painted wooden sign on the wall behind her reads "THE GREEN ROOM". A small chalkboard on the counter reads "REPOTTING EVERY SATURDAY". A paper tag tied to the pot reads "FERN 14". Low warm sun through the front window lighting her face, dust in the light, shelves of plants softly blurred, shallow depth of field, natural skin texture, the text must be exact, no other text anywhere.

Editorial portrait

Ideogram 4.6: Editorial portrait
Ideogram 4.6
Seedream 5.5: Editorial portrait
Seedream 5.5

This is the second try on Ideogram 4.6, after a first with the wrong proportions. It shows him from the waist up in a cable knit sweater, with mist and a boat behind him. Seedream 5.5 went in tight on his face, as the prompt asked, with sharper skin detail and sea spray.

Tight beauty editorial portrait on an 85mm lens at f/2: a strikingly handsome man in his early thirties with thick dark tousled hair, a sharp jawline, light stubble and warm hazel eyes, in a navy fisherman sweater, turns toward the camera with a slight confident smile on a harbor wall at dawn as sea mist drifts behind him, soft silver light with a faint warm glow from the left, individual hairs and wool fibers visible, natural skin texture, fine color negative film grain, magazine cover quality, no text.

Product shot with a label

Ideogram 4.6: Product shot with a label
Ideogram 4.6
Seedream 5.5: Product shot with a label
Seedream 5.5

Both wrote DEW NO. 5 cleanly on frosted glass with mint on wet slate. Ideogram 4.6 used a flat gold cap and put exactly three drops on the glass. Seedream 5.5 framed the label in a thin box and used a dropper cap.

Studio product photograph on a 100mm macro lens: a frosted glass bottle of pale green skincare serum with a brushed gold cap stands on a wet slab of dark slate, three water droplets on the glass, one sprig of fresh mint beside it, hard rim light from the right, soft fill from the left, deep forest green gradient background, crisp reflections, advertising quality, photoreal. The label on the bottle reads "DEW NO. 5" in thin black capitals, the text must be exact, no other text.

Concert poster

Ideogram 4.6: Concert poster
Ideogram 4.6
Seedream 5.5: Concert poster
Seedream 5.5

Every line is right on both. Ideogram 4.6 made a flat poster: solid orange, a plain silhouette and big condensed capitals. Seedream 5.5 drew more into it: an art deco headline, brick rooftops, clouds and a paper border.

Flat vector concert poster in a mid-century style. Headline at the top reads "SUNDOWN SESSIONS" in tall cream geometric capitals. Below it a smaller line reads "LIVE JAZZ ON THE ROOF". Central illustration: a trumpet player in silhouette against a huge orange sun with city rooftops below. At the bottom a line reads "EVERY FRIDAY 8 PM" and under it "TICKETS AT THE DOOR". Palette of burnt orange, cream, teal and charcoal, subtle paper grain, the text must be exact, no other text anywhere.

Infographic

Ideogram 4.6: Infographic
Ideogram 4.6
Seedream 5.5: Infographic
Seedream 5.5

Both have the title and all four labels. Ideogram 4.6 drew thin line icons on four tidy cards. Seedream 5.5 drew fuller, filled icons and wrote 94°C with a degree sign.

Clean flat infographic on a cream background titled "HOW TO BREW POUR OVER COFFEE" in bold dark brown capitals at the top. Four numbered steps in a row, each with a simple icon and a short label under it: step 1 a scale icon with the label "WEIGH 20 G", step 2 a kettle icon with the label "HEAT TO 94 C", step 3 a dripper icon with the label "BLOOM 30 SEC", step 4 a cup icon with the label "POUR IN CIRCLES". Thin arrows between the steps, palette of dark brown, terracotta and sage green, the text must be exact, no other text anywhere.

Food photo

Ideogram 4.6: Food photo
Ideogram 4.6
Seedream 5.5: Food photo
Seedream 5.5

Neither shot it from straight overhead. Both came in at an angle by the window, with steam, chili oil, pickles and iced tea. Ideogram 4.6 showed both halves of the egg and added a fourth slice of pork. Seedream 5.5 kept to three slices.

Overhead food photograph on a 50mm lens: a blue ceramic bowl of ramen with a soft egg cut in half, three slices of pork, spring onion, a sheet of nori and chili oil catching the light, wooden chopsticks resting on the rim, a small dish of pickles and a glass of iced tea beside it on a dark walnut table, steam rising, hard window light from the top left with long shadows, photoreal, no text.

Run your own test

Both models are on Pixel Dojo. Copy any prompt above and try it on each.